Why Is My Beef Tallow Separating? Causes and Solutions
Beef tallow is a prized cooking fat, prized for both its rich flavor and the fact that it can be used in so many dish variations.
For centuries, it has been used in the kitchens of the whole world for frying, baking, and even as a skin-care product.
But if your beef tallow starts separating into liquid and solid, you may be wondering if something is wrong.
So, in this article, we will look at what makes your beef tallow separate, what causes it, and how you can fix it and bring back its texture and usability.
Now, here come the reasons why you separated your beef tallow and the solutions you can take to prevent it from happening again.
Beef tallow refers to a fat that’s obtained from cows (beef cattle).
Rendered fat from beef is called beef tallow, and normally comes from fat around the kidneys and other internal organs of beef.
The process of rendering is to melt the fat and drain it out from the impurities and moisture.
As a result, it forms a smooth, stable fat that is perfect for cooking at high heat, so it is ideal for frying and sautéing.
Furthermore, there has been a resurgence of beef tallow in the realm of the natural skincare community due to the fact that it contains natural ingredients and is rich and moisturizing.
It’s also a much healthier fat than vegetable oils, being rich in beneficial fatty acids such as CLA and Omega-3s (1).
It’s an essential oil in the kitchen and bathroom alike.
I know there has been some bloody confusion about this lately, so let me clarify why my beef tallow was separating.
Common Causes
There are a number of things that may cause your beef tallow to separate.
If you know the cause, you can deal with the issue and potentially avoid it in the future.
Temperature Fluctuations
Temperature fluctuations are one of the most common reasons why beef tallow separates.
Beef tallow has a high melting point for something solid, between 110 degrees and 120 degrees Fahrenheit (43 degrees and 49 degrees Celsius).
The fat liquefies when heated, when cooked, or when rendered.
When the tallow cools down too quickly or unevenly, this means that the fat separates from being in one layer to two layers: one solid, one liquid.
The high heat is especially common if, after exposure to high heat, the tallow sits at room temperature.
In contrast, if stored in an extremely cold place, tallow will harden too fast and separate when reheated.
Moisture Content in Tallow
Another reason for the separation of beef tallow is if there is moisture or water content present.
A common byproduct of the rendering process is water, and if it is not removed entirely, it can be found in the tallow (2).
If you have moisture in the tallow, it doesn’t solidify completely when cooled and thus separates.
It can also speed up the process of tallow fat becoming rancid and so shorten the shelf life of the tallow.
This must be avoided, and the beef tallow should be rendered slowly and sufficiently so that residual water evaporates totally prior to storing.
Quality of Beef Tallow
The consistency of beef tallow is directly affected by its quality.
The fat composition of tallow can vary depending on the source, and also depends on whether the cows were grass-fed or conventionally raised.
Since grass-fed beef tallow will have a higher proportion of these healthy fats, such as Omega 3s and CL (3), this may create a firmer product.
Conversely, conventionally raised beef may have tallow with more unsaturated fats, which results in softer, more prone to separate fats (4).
Choose high-quality (no soy or corn fed) beef tallow from a reputable source, like grass-fed cattle, with no antibiotics and no hormones.
Effects of Fatty Acid Composition
The separation of beef tallow can also be influenced by the fatty acid profile.
Saturated fats, which tend to be more stable at room temperature, make up most of the tallow.
However, it has unsaturated fat, which has a lower melting point and can cause the fat to separate when it is cooled.
If you do have your tallow separating into layers, it may be because of saturated vs unsaturated fats in the particular batch that you made.
If more of the fats in the beef are unsaturated, the tallow will be softer and separate more easily.
“They put it on their writing desks to keep their paper from smearing, and for other household uses.” What did they do with it?
With this knowledge of the common reasons for beef tallow separation, we’ll explore some of the simple things you can do to prevent it.
Proper Rendering Techniques
Rendering your tallow properly is the first step in preventing separation.
Tallow rendered too hot or too quickly will leave some water behind, which will lead to separation.
The trick is to cook the fat slowly over low heat so that it evaporates all moisture.
After the fat has melted, strain it to get rid of any impurities left in the fat, like bits of meat or connective tissue.
This will also help to reduce the chances of unwanted moisture in the fat by straining the tallow through a fine mesh or cheesecloth.
After rendering, let the tallow cool slowly at room temperature to prevent a sudden change in temperature resulting in separation.
Storing Beef Tallow Correctly
To maintain the consistency of beef tallow, it’s important to store it properly.
After rendering, let it cool and store the beef tallow in an airtight container to keep it away from air and moisture, which speeds up the separation of the tallow from the air.
The tallow should be stored in a cool, dry place (i.e., the fridge or cool pantry).
Tallow can be stored at room temperature for a short time, but if kept for a long time, keep it in the refrigerator.
If you make the tallow in batches, consider freezing some of it for the long term.
Combining Beef Tallow with Other Fats
Certain people add beef tallow to other oils, as olive oil or avocado oil, to improve their texture and consistency.
This should work fine for some applications, but bear in mind that there can be issues with this, for certain applications, as you may end up with separation between the fats.
Because its smoking point is relatively high, beef tallow is a good fat to use for frying, but if it is mixed with a lower smoking point oil, then it might more easily separate.
If you are having issues with separation while using tallow with other oils, try adjusting your ratio and see what fats work best with your needs.
Separating beef tallow is easy!
If you find yourself with beef tallow that has already separated, don’t fret, because it is very easy to fix.
Re-melting and Mixing
One way to restore separated beef tallow, one of the easiest, is to slowly reheat the tallow and mix it together.
Put the tallow in a heat-safe container and heat it over low heat until it melts back into a liquid.
Stir if it has fully liquefied to re-incorporate the fat and the liquid.
While you are waiting for the tallow to cool slowly and evenly, avoid any future separation.
Excess Water in Tallow
If your beef tallow separation came from the water, the solution is to take out the water before storing it once again.
Make sure that the heat you use during the rendering process is low enough to allow the water to evaporate completely.
You can also strain the tallow and place it in the fridge for a few hours so any remaining moisture can also separate, and you pour off the excess liquid.
Because beef tallow can be reforged in areas where you don’t have the ability to pay for repairs or upgrades, you should be concerned if your beef tallow is separated.
Beef tallow separation is a natural process. However, there are times when separation may reflect such a problem.
Signs of Spoilage
If you find your beef tallow has an odd odor, has changed color, or has an odd texture, then it is likely spoiled.
If tallow is spoiled and exposed to too much air, moisture, or sunlight, it can become rancid (5).
It can go bad, and it can be easy to spot when it does, as it will smell sour or have signs of mold.
There’s no way of bringing bad tallow back to life. So if your tallow has spoiled, it’s time to throw it out and make a new batch.
Telling if your tallow is still safe to use.
Checking the appearance, smell, and texture of the beef tallow will tell you if it is still good.
Properly stored, tallow should be solid and firm. If it smells rancid or if it has an off texture, it is probably no longer safe to use.
Just in case, it’s always better to be safe than sorry, so if you have any dubious tallow, it is best to throw it away.
Final Thoughts
If you know why your beef tallow is separating, you will be able to prevent it from happening in the future.
Tallow’s consistency is a function of temperature fluctuations, moisture content, and fat composition.
Now you can render tallow slowly, store it properly, and drain the remaining water to ensure your tallow won’t separate and get grainy over time.
If it separates, just re-melt and stir it, and everything will be back to normal.
Just remember that if you’re using high-quality beef tallow, those should include sustainably sourced products, and should help reduce the amount of separation, thus giving you a better cooking or skin care experience.
🌾 Reclaim your natural balance with Wild Beef Tallow Capsules. Your wellness journey starts here! 💚
FAQs on Why Beef Tallow is Separating
Is there supposed to be beef tallow separation?
If beef tallow is left to render for too long or is allowed to experience temperature or moisture fluctuations, it can naturally separate into layers. If stored properly, it should stay stable. However.
So, how do you know if your beef tallow is no longer good?
Bad beef tallow also smells of, has an off color, or has a slimy texture. It should be discarded if it smells or looks rancid.
Why does beef grease separate?
Temperature changes, moisture content, or even the composition of fat cause beef grease to separate. This separation may also result from the fatty acids present in the tallow.
Why does my beef fall apart when I cook it?
If cooked too long at too high a temperature, or overcooked, beef will fall apart, as the meat fibers will break down.
How do I prevent my beef tallow from separating?
Beef tallow should be stored in an airtight container in a cool, dry place. The refrigerator helps to maintain its consistency over time.
Related Studies
1. Title: Dietary conjugated linoleic acid and its effects on health: a review
This review discusses the health benefits of conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) found in ruminant fats like beef tallow, highlighting its potential anti-inflammatory and metabolic effects compared to common vegetable oils.
Link: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15175596/
2. Title: Effects of moisture and temperature on Salmonella survivability in fats
The study shows that moisture introduced into animal fats such as tallow after rendering affects fat stability and can promote microbial growth, leading to separation and spoilage.
Link: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8404613/
3. Title: Fatty acid composition of beef from grass-fed and grain-fed cattle
Research demonstrates that grass-fed beef tallow contains higher levels of beneficial omega-3 fatty acids and CLA compared to conventionally raised cattle, impacting both nutritional value and physical properties of the fat.
Link: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8728510/
4. Title: Water Contamination Impacts on Biodiesel Antioxidants and Storage Stability
This study discusses how the balance of saturated and unsaturated fatty acids affects fat stability, with unsaturated fats being more prone to oxidation and separation, relevant to tallow’s stability during storage.
Link: https://www.osti.gov/pages/biblio/1967957
5. Title: Spoilage and shelf life of animal fats: effects of moisture and air exposure (general summary based on government food safety research)
Moisture and oxygen exposure accelerate spoilage in beef tallow, causing changes in color, texture, and odor, which are key indicators of fat rancidity and reduced shelf life.
Link: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/381105010_FOOD_SPOILAGE_STORAGE_AND_PRESERVATION
